Help me make a Buy/Sell Decision

lamborghinifan · 09-03-2011, 06:48 PM

Ok, I'm just at a crossroads with my ute, 2004 BA mk2, dual fuel. 4sp auto.
Love driving it, has most of the bits (bullbar, alloys, ipod, tranny cooler, undertray toolbox, spotties) i want, but as i am considering working for myself and will constantly carry about toolboxes, ladders etc, the 4sp just doesn't cut it when it comes to say slipping a quick right hand turn etc, just needs that extra gear with the weight on board.
until now it's mostly been an empty highway cruiser, i've owned it since nearly new, after my grandfather bought it new, and it has 110k on it. it owes me nothing and i am prepared so spend a few say, $2-5k to get what i want.

my questions:
Is it possible/feasible to slot in a 5sp auto, are they much better?

I drove a 5sp manual today, liked it, but i imagine would not be a feasible conversion. Are these a weaker setup, and how do they go with GAS.

Is is better selling (12-14k) and upgrading to say a bf mk2 manual (14-18k), do they come in a 5sp auto? I still like the ba-f shape and interior.

Also to remember is I have had the LPG conversion done. it has well and truly paid for itself, but it is the mixer setup, so a little sluggish. I would probably convert if I upgraded with an injected system.

any thoughts/experiences appreciated

AUIIISR · 09-03-2011, 08:53 PM

Ive got a BA MKII XL work ute, 212xxxkms 5 speed manual, still drives brand new, honestly best car ive ever had for a daily, only things done to it are front hubs replaced and rear brakes at 200000, regular services, upgraded H/D rear suspension was the best thing I ever put in it, will take a cube of conmix on the back and hardly faze it. 5 speed is strong enough for me, its done several trips to sydney and melbourne towing cars, no problems 4th @ 100kmh, tonnes of landscape work etc etc. Good utes I'd say the BF would be just as good. Its due for trade in at 220xxx am looking at a 4x4 ranger single cab and deck it out

happy1 · 10-03-2011, 11:57 AM

Hi,
I think adding more gears to your auto wouldn't fix it if the real problem is lack of power due to the gas conversion.
The next step up from your BA 4 speed auto is the BF 6-speed auto, however that conversion requires full re-wiring, new PCM, new propeller shaft, and a whole lot of parts. In other words better to trade it for something, and get another one rather than even thinking about conversion.
The only conversion that is fairly simple these days is to swap in a XR6Turbo from BA into your BA. You would need to replace the gas system to one that suits turbo. You should be able to find an engine & gearbox package from an XR6T for approx $ 4500,
Again, if you sell your ute, and purchase a turbo ute, then fit a sequential gas system you are probably where you want to be? Cheers

DEVO'S MB XR5T · 10-03-2011, 12:18 PM

Well, I reckon if you are thinking of starting your own business you should keep the ute you have. (nothing wrong with it, Reliable) You don't want to be paying off a new ute while getting your business up and running...
But if you have to get a new ute, I would go with an Auto and dedicated LPG motor?
When you are driving and the phone rings, (offcourse on hands free) you would have a free hand to write numbers, quick notes, and at the last minute make that quick right turn!! if you had a manual you might miss out on the client!!

ZA-289 · 10-03-2011, 01:51 PM

So whats the problem again?....

lamborghinifan · 10-03-2011, 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZA-289

So whats the problem again?....

ha thanks, actually, the bare roots problem is that i probably just need someone to tell me it's actually allright, leave it be.
I have an injected LPG system in my territory, love it, but to change the system is nearly as much as a full conversion. and no rebate this time!

XRGhia · 10-03-2011, 01:54 PM

get a 6-speed manual from a turbo...

stronger, and you have 6 gears

**Mechan1k** · 12-03-2011, 06:19 AM

If it is going to be a work ute ... leave it at that ... to make it a fun throw-around ute and work ute ... while retaining LPG will start costing you.

By all means do some mods ... but a transmission conversion is not going to be easy ... the 5-speed autos are in the FG ... so not really set up for the B-series when i comes to PCM control ... ZF conversion ... PRICEY. Especially for the vehicle you have.

If it does everything perfectly for work ... leave it at that really. Reliability is more important than having the ute spend time off the road.