View Single Post
Old 19-10-2023, 11:18 AM   #18
Trevor 57
FF.Com.Au Hardcore
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 7,517
Default Re: Victoria’s electric vehicle tax thrown out by High Court

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wretched View Post
I think the whole folly of "EV users not paying their way" is just that, a folly and a whinge.

EV drivers paid tax on their car (GST, LCT & stamp duty), not forgetting ongoing registrations as well. EV users are tax payers who pay an income tax. They also pay a GST on their electricity bill.
and so did I when I bought my diesel Ranger and when working and when buying diesel - nothing new there ol' mate. Electricity is not taxed like petrol or diesel


Quote:
Originally Posted by Wretched View Post
Don't forget not everyone pays the same amount of excise. I have a car that runs about 6l/100km, I technically drive on the road more than our friend with his 5.0l V8 but he pays more "tax."
I don't agree on subsidising the purchase of any EV cars or anything like that.

Are we going to get to a point in time where it becomes a user pay system? Cause I sure as hell don't want that. Imagine the health system turning into pay as you go instead of it being funded for everyone?

This is an opportunity for the federal and state governments to review road funding as a whole, the excise goes into general revenue at the federal level. So it never funded state roads.

If collecting tax is your concern, then I am sure you'd be keen to object to the stage 3 tax cuts, reviewing the tax breaks on "work vehicles" and other loopholes that leak billions in possible tax revenue.
why should I (through my diesel and petrol excises) subsidise your road use? e.g wear and tear of the road network. Your post (and others) sounds an awful like a 'minority whinge' to me

The sooner another tax is introduced the better
Trevor 57 is offline   Reply With Quote